Hello dear
Welcome To Forgotten Taste Pierogies
Welcome to Forgotten Taste Pierogies, a hidden gem located in Wexford, PA. This charming eatery specializes in authentic homemade pierogies, capturing the essence of traditional Polish cuisine. Customers rave about the flavorful kielbasa, rich sauerkraut, and delectably soft pierogies, often boasting about their generous portion sizes. The warm, family-oriented service adds a personal touch, making every visit feel like coming home. Whether you indulge in the spinach and ricotta pierogies or their renowned pepperoni and cheese variety, each bite promises to transport you to fond memories of yesteryear. With take-out options and frozen selections available, Forgotten Taste Pierogies ensures the authentic experience can be savored anytime.
Taste the best
Discover Our Menu
Frozen
Potato & Cheese
Stuffed Pepper, 4 Potato & Cheese Pierogies, Haluski
US$12.49
Kielbasa, Haluski & Sauerkraut
US$12.99Stuffed Cabbage, 4 Potato & Cheese Pierogies, Sauerkraut
US$12.49Haluski, 4 Potato & Cheese Pierogies, Green Beans
US$11.09
Hot Sausage Goulash Over 6 Potato & Cheese Pierogies
US$12.99Kielbasa, 4 Potato & Cheese Pierogies, Sauerkraut
US$12.99Cabbage
About
Forgotten Taste Pierogies
Welcome to the delightful world of Forgotten Taste Pierogies, a hidden gem nestled in Wexford, Pennsylvania. Specializing in authentic Polish cuisine, this quaint eatery has quickly become the go-to destination for those craving the comforting embrace of traditional pierogies and hearty Eastern European fare.
The moment you step through the door, you’re greeted by the warm smiles of the staff, who are often heard conversing in their native language, setting a genuine atmosphere that promises culinary authenticity. As you immerse yourself in the cozy surroundings, you can almost feel the love and care infused in every dish. Customers rave about the homey feeling, often comparing the service to being welcomed by family.
As for the food, it’s nothing short of spectacular. The pierogies are the stars of the show, with notable favorites like the spinach and ricotta, which one customer described as “melting in your mouth.” Each dumpling is crafted with delicate care, bursting with exquisite flavors and textures that leave patrons longing for more. The pepperoni and cheese pierogies are particularly praised, hailed as a must-try that stands out among the competition in an area rich with Polish eateries.
Beyond the pierogies, Forgotten Taste offers a well-rounded menu featuring delicious kielbasa that’s perfectly seasoned and sauerkraut that has an explosion of flavor. The haluski and stuffed cabbage dishes evoke nostalgia, reminiscent of cherished family recipes. Portions are generous, ensuring you leave satisfied without breaking the bank.
Convenience is key here; whether you decide to dine in or take out, the process is streamlined for your enjoyment. With options to purchase frozen pierogies to enjoy at home, it’s a thoughtful touch for those who want to savor a taste of forgetting while making memories with family and friends.
If you’re on a quest for expertly crafted pierogies and authentic Polish flavors, look no further than Forgotten Taste Pierogies. From the delicious food to the welcoming atmosphere, this establishment is not just a meal, but an experience. So, whether you’re a long-time lover of pierogies or a first-time visitor, prepare to indulge your taste buds and make some unforgettable culinary memories.
Visit them at 11978 US-19, Wexford, PA 15090 or call +1 724-940-2277 to get your fill of what customers are calling “the best pierogies” they’ve ever had!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ I walked in and two ladies with thick accents welcomed me...I knew one of two things would happen next, either this would be great or it would be a bust. Thankfully, it was the former; this small place has great food! Kielbasa had good flavor without being greasy, the sauerkraut exploded with flavor, the pierogi were delectable but would have preferred browned onions, the haluski is a meal in itself, and the stuffed cabbage and peppers were like I used to remember growing up. Everything here was great and at an affordable price. Hopefully this taste stays here and won't be forgotten. ”
“ Here is the quick summary for the review scanners if you want genuine polish food this is the place to go. For the people who like the details here is the story. You know an ethnic place is going to be good when it's ran by women who are speaking the language when you walk in. The service was excellent, it felt like you were being served by a family member. They serve everything is packages and you pay at the register so you can drop in for take out or take advantage of the tables they have and eat there but either way when your ready to go it's a get up and go type of thing. In regards to beverages they have a standing fridge full of coke products in plastic bottles for you to select from. They have many different platters for you to select from or if you like you can order individual items a la carte. They also have deserts which we took advantage of and they are very generous when it comes to portion sizes. My family had everything the offered to try them all and all were excellent however you are likely reading this because you saw Pierogie in the name of this place and I am pleased to say no matter which type of pierogi you get you are going to be very pleased. The pierogi's were soft and delicate and the filling was exquisite in taste and texture. Final bonus is they have everything available frozen if you would like to take some for home and warm up on your schedule. Handy for folks who drove some distance to try this place and want to have some later when it's convenient for them. ”
“ THE BEST PIEROGIES IVE EVER HAD. I used to go to downtown Pittsburgh for my pierogies but I won’t be making that long drive now that I’ve discovered this restaurant. These are so much better. The customer service was great and all the food was fresh and delicious. My favorite was the spinach and ricotta pierogies, but the gnocchi melts in your mouth so perfectly! Just FYI there wasn’t a changing table in case you visit with babies, but hopefully that changes in the future ”
“ Friendly staff and amazing food! Get the #3 and get the Colossal Cheesecake! ”
“ As a Pittsburgher who knows their pierogies, I can confidently say Forgotten Taste Pierogies in Wexford is one of the best local spots to grab a dozen (or two)! With over 20 companies and countless churches making pierogies in the area, it can be hard to stand out, but Forgotten Taste does just that. Their pepperoni and cheese pierogies are a must-try – seriously delicious! The owner is incredibly friendly and has such a warm personality that makes you feel right at home. If you’re in the area and craving authentic, homemade pierogies, this is the place to go. Always a pleasure to support a small business with great food and even better service. Highly recommend! ”
“ Okay, the food here is amazing. Soft perogies, satisfying bowtie haluski, hearty kielbasa, sweet sauce on the stuffed cabbage and delicious sour kraut (and I've never been a fan) Tou can take out or dine in. Very small restaurant so few seating options and they will serve your meal in to go boxes and they have only disposable cutlery. No fountain drinks, just bottles in a cooler. Can't wait to try more perogies flavors!!! ”
“ Wanted to find the best pierogi in Pittsburgh and drove outside of downtown to find them. Do not skip this place in your pierogi journey!!! The best my Polish dad says he’s had in decades! ”
“ Some of the best perogies I've had in or around Pittsburgh. The meatballs and spicy sausage (not actually spicy in my opinion but hot sauce is available) are terrific, too. Service was quick and friendly. ”